Sean Dyche has a unique situation when Everton receives a double injury update.

Sean Dyche faces a pleasant conundrum with his midfield options ahead of the match against Crystal Palace. Abdoulaye Doucoure’s recovery from a hamstring injury, coupled with

Amadou Onana’s return to fitness, means Dyche now has his top four senior

central midfielders available, following a period marred by injuries and Idrissa

Gueye’s participation in the Africa Cup of Nations.

With the preferred formation likely to accommodate only three of these midfielders, speculation arises regarding who might be benched. Various Everton reporters weigh in on this dilemma:

1. Joe Thomas suggests resting James Garner for the Palace game, emphasizing his consistent performance despite facing rigorous demands during the congested fixture schedule. Thomas believes Garner deserves a break to avoid potential burnout, especially considering his pivotal role in the absence of teammates.
2. Connor O’Neill advocates for Garner’s inclusion, highlighting his importance to the team’s midfield and footballing prowess. While acknowledging Onana’s potential, O’Neill prioritizes Garner’s presence on the field, particularly against a team like Crystal Palace, where Everton might see more possession.
3. Matt Jones proposes rotating Garner out of the starting lineup, considering his heavy workload throughout the season. Jones argues that while Garner remains a crucial asset, providing depth and impact off the bench, a brief respite could benefit him and the team in the short term.

Ultimately, Dyche must weigh the merits of each perspective to make the best decision for Everton’s midfield lineup against Crystal Palace.